Originally Posted by
djheydt
Where are you going to get the tomatoes?
They're a New World plant, and Tolkien
seems to have realized that between the
first and second editions of The Hobbit,
which mentions "cold chicken and tomatoes"
in the first and changes to "cold chicken and
pickles" in the second.
As to taters, we must assume the Elves brought
them to Numenor along with pipeweed, and
they were carried thence to Middle-earth by
Amandir's nine tall ships.
Anyway, I like Sapience, and I would rather
throw flowers. (As a Historian, I have quite
a lot of them in my vault.)