Middle-earth Feedback: Elrond

[Ramen]

Travel now to the Last Homely House in Rivendell, where you will meet Elrond Halfelven, keeper of much otherwise long-forgotten lore.

Read about Elrond, then post your comments below!

[Reodred14]

Poor Elrond, he's all the way back to the last page

[Spazzmodic]

Elrond bugs me. As far as I can tell, the whole ongoing fight against Sauron is a result of him not acting when Isildor refused to throw the ring into Mt Doom. I'm sure he could have forced the issue or killed Isildor. He knew without a doubt what needed to be done and failed to do it.

as for the link: "404 Error: Page not found"

so, I guess the story of Elrond is lost to the ages

[cyimri]

Elrond bugs me. As far as I can tell, the whole ongoing fight against Sauron is a result of him not acting when Isildor refused to throw the ring into Mt Doom. I'm sure he could have forced the issue or killed Isildor. He knew without a doubt what needed to be done and failed to do it.

Wow... call a guy out why don't you... Good thing you weren't at the council of Elrond (Fellowship of the Ring). Could have been uncomfortable...

Elrond: I have summoned you to this council...
Spazzmo: So you can explain how this is all YOUR fault?

...uncomfortable silence...

[mrsleep]

Elrond bugs me. As far as I can tell, the whole ongoing fight against Sauron is a result of him not acting when Isildor refused to throw the ring into Mt Doom. I'm sure he could have forced the issue or killed Isildor. He knew without a doubt what needed to be done and failed to do it.

While I can understand the feeling, the bearer of the ring has proven to be quite difficult to kill, historically. Perhaps he tried, and Isildor just put it on and ran away.