Consider these two pages. They both use the same template, and each template includes an image of the same size. Both source images are also the same resolution.
This one works:
http://lorebook.lotro.com/wiki/Landm...el%27s_Vinyard
This one results in a blank thumbnail, but the image is there if you go to the source file page:
http://lorebook.lotro.com/wiki/Landmark:Big_Staddlemere
Unfortunately, looking over the landmark pages I'd made back in the day, more of these images seem to fail than succeed. Reuploading the old image made no difference.
Thanks