Isengard deed bug or as intended ?

[Marguerita]

Today i did using Instance finder (new tool):

- Protecting the Forest in the Fanghorn's Edge 3-man instance T1. i obtained the challenge quest and completed it.

The quest 'Thorn in the Hand' completed that part, and when i left, there was still running :
Complete Dargnákh's Rage in the Dargnákh Unleashed 3-man instance
Complete the Into the Pit of Abomination in the Pits of Isengard 3-man instance

----

I went to help a friend in the Dargnakh Unleashed instance, we made it.

I was rewarded and when i left the instance, the quest Thorn in the hand needed
Complete the Into the Pit of Abomination in the Pits of Isengard 3-man instance

---------

A little later, we decided to go for another instance, wishing to have The Pit.
We were sent into Fanghorn's Edge 3-man instance, but i crashed as always in entering that instance.

After reloging, I noticed my quest 'Thorn in the Hand' was changed, and that i had now to Protect the forest again.
We decided to left the instance and run The Pit through the old tool Instance join, even if less rewards.

We made it. We killed each boss.

Then i realised that i never had any message as usually in that instance.
And that the bosses kills did not updated. I was rewarded each time with medallions and seals and sigyl, but the deeds did not advanced.

If i check my quest log it shows that i have completed The 3 quests asked by THorn in the hand, but
- the deed Commanders of the Isengard T1 did not advanced for killing Dargnákh'
- The deed The army of Isengard did not updated the part concerning Thorn in the hand, though i have completed it.
- and i am still running Thorn in the Hand in my quest log with Fanghorn's Edge to do again....

--------------

I may of course dont understand the way it works, for those deeds, so if i am wrong, then please just ignore this.
But i think that something went wrong when we abandonned Fanghorn's Edge and took the Instance join (old tool).

THank you

[Catisa]

the deed Commanders of the Isengard T1 did not advanced for killing Dargnákh'

^ that one you must actually kill, as in DPS down, dargnakh, you will not complete the deed if you kill him by exposing him to the sun

[Marguerita]

the deed Commanders of the Isengard T1 did not advanced for killing Dargnákh'

^ that one you must actually kill, as in DPS down, dargnakh, you will not complete the deed if you kill him by exposing him to the sun

Oh thank you! at least i know why this deed did not updated.

Still left with Thorn in the Hand problem

[Rapunzel666]

Oh thank you! at least i know why this deed did not updated.

Still left with Thorn in the Hand problem

better a thorn in the hand than a rock on your head!

sorry, couldn't resist

[andrane]

in general, all t1 deeds will not update if you finish a t2 or t2hm run.
thats a bug

[Marguerita]

in general, all t1 deeds will not update if you finish a t2 or t2hm run.
thats a bug

Is it also bugged if you do T1 ?

i am a learning healer and not confident yet for t2, so for now i will just do a lot of t1, a sort of training.
I will probably do some t2 but with friends who knows i can unfortunatly make some mistake still, that way no stress but only fun while learning.
I need also more power and one more piece of set armor. Then i will switch to t2

[Tarmas_Eldar]

The deeds for the instances don't advance from an instance completion as such, they actually advance from completion of the particular quests you get on entering the instance. There are separate quests for T1 and T2, which is why the T1 deed does not update when you complete T2.

So this isn't exactly a bug because it does work as designed. It may be an oversight, however, that this means not completing the T1 deed from a T2 run (which is what *does* happen in Orthanc and in all previous T1/T2 instances). The obvious answer would be to have the T1 quest also bestowed when you do a T2 run, thus allowing both to be completed at once.

Now, the T1 Dargnakh quest requiring you to actually kill him (as opposed to using the light from 4 corner collapses) looks like a bug. This arguably makes the fight harder because you will have to deal with more AoE poundings since the fight inevitably takes longer.

[Kril]

The one that ticked me off was Clear Cutter. Doesn't specify T2, but doesn't complete under T1.

[Marguerita]

Well today we did Dargnakh not with the pillars and completed the deed for Commanders of the Isengard t1.

So this is corrected for me.

Then it appears that i had bugged myself the quest Thorn in the hands, as i totally forgot when i did the isntance, to speak with the Ent at the end.....

So today we did it again, i spoke with him and my quest advanced for : Complete Ringing of the Hammer in the Foundry 6man instance.

So yes there is some strange things with deeds but i think those at least where only coming from my side.

Thank you to all who answered