Quote Originally Posted by Sapience View Post
The image is oversize and doesn't relate directly to LOTRO and is basically a billboard for your site. So it's advertising and a violation of the guidelines.

Whiteberry's is right on the line. It is at least LOTRO related, though still closer to billboard for a site than a signature identifying you.

I'm trying to work out how to get a full list into the sig creator or at least adding it to the community guidelines. The need to make it tri-lingual may be a challenge in the signature creator page.
I'm already seeing every argument that was used against my decision to allow this on the forums. I may have to admit I was dead wrong and remove the ability.

I've updated the OP with a much more complete list.
Thanks for the clarification.

I find that on many sites, people signatures become so large and unwieldy, that they end up being the focal point. Reading a thread can become quite hard as a result, especially with lower resolution screens. So if the process can be effectively policed but at the same time allow people to identify themselves uniquely then it's a win, win situation.