
Originally Posted by
Ethrildar
1) An RK is 99% grey-barred while silenced, no, it cannot outheal two creeps or even one creep when silenced, you're a moron.
2) Scribe a New Ending cures 1 debuff every 2 seconds, every creep class has at least 2 (some have up to 5) potable debuffs which you can apply before your silence/disarm, so they waste this skill on curing those, not the disarm/silence. The skills cooldown is longer than it's effect by 33% and it has a 1.5 second lead-time so it's immensely clunky and doesn't fit in with a rotation, it also can't be used whilst silenced, so just apply your disarm then silence the RK and voila, it's 100% greybarred and cannot do anything for 5-10 seconds.
3) 50% of silences? On my warg I'd say it's more like 5%, combat analysis seems to agree with this.
4) Better heals than defis? When not CC'd sure they do, single target heals on themselves only, if not harrassed by one warg. With one warg, a RK is likely to get off 1/4 of it's inductions, which takes it's healing down from defiler-level heals to more like red cappy level heals. If you can't harrass a healing RK to this point, again, you're playing your warg WRONG.
5) 13k bubbles? The largest bubble a RK can place is a 6.8k bubble on a cooldown CD assuming full attunement, aka, not from the very start. No idea where you've got 13k from, although I'd assume it's the same place as where you got "defilers aren't that strong healers" from.
6) DPS RKs have two things they can use, in fire-line they have a 15 sec CD 5k heal, which can't be used whilst disarmed, aside from that they can bubble themselves for 2-6.8k assuming they take the time out of doing any DPS to use this, which would be detrimental since a 7k bubble is 3 hits from Bestial Claws, exluding all other rotational skills. A lightning RK hasn't even got the 5k heal, it's got sustaining bolt, a 2k heal on a 15 sec CD, which whilst clearly a MASSIVE MASSIVE self-heal, is really not that bad.
In response to your argument that DPS RKs have way too much survivability, but you faceroll them on your warg anyway, what more need I say, you can FACEROLL A CLASS that you think is overpowered? I won't even go into CD-spamming reavers that have about as much survivability as every freep class combined all in one, although personally I have no issue with reavers, talking about the survivability of a freepside low-morale, low-mits induction class as overpowered whilst in the same sentence saying how you can faceroll any RK anyway, is just beyond comprehension.
.............. Defiler healing is WAY, WAY better than RK healing UNLESS the RK is left to just heal as much as it likes with no CC, harrassment from any 1 creep, no debuffs, and if there's a warg on it, say goodbye to anything it's trying to heal.