Update to:

Quest: Thief-taker's Bane
Category: Evendim
Journal Level: 38
Journal Icon: fellowship
Actual Level: 45 as is, without changing the fellowship to raid
Actual Icon: Small Raid
Reasons: My lvl 46 hunter has tried about 8 times to complete this quest. The first 4-5 times, I was with a group of mostly 39-41 players. Even with a good mix of dps, healing, and guardian to hold agro, those darned rangers died.

Update: the first few tries, the spawns came at regularly spaced intervals in this pattern - camp 1, camp 3, then camp 2, back to camp 1, and over again. After the new patch and chat hotfix, they are now random. This forces the group to split up. Even at lvl 46, my hunter takes too long to kill these elites, and the rangers got overwhelmed.


Fix: Either make those darned rangers more durable (and add their health bars to our screens) or make the elites a bit easier to kill. This quest needs some serious tweaking to make it doable at level 38.