Book 3.1.4: Halros' Decision

[Majesto]

Just a comment, it really depends how much they are following the movies vs how much the novels. All of the ending events from the novels are left out of the movies, so in one sense at least Turbine can do whatever they like with the Shire.

Turbine's license is for the books, not the movies. That's why Aragorn has Anduril before he leaves Rivendell, we have Tom Bombadill, etc. We've already seen what happens with the Tuckborough skirmish.

Is Halros supposed to be Halbarad's brother? Perhaps we'll get something to that effect when Halbarad perishes on the Pelennor Fields.

Anyway, I sent Halros on, since that was the plan from Elrond, and I also thought that if he stayed in the Shire he'd probably end up slain. I couldn't have that on my conscience.

Nice catch with 3.1.4 and pi.