The members of the Grey Company and their fates?

[Tirian-Hammerfist]

I can probably at least cross off the names of those who didn't make it out of Tur Morva, since it's been so long. I reserve the right to bring any of these guys back if I've gotten their names wrong or confused them with someone else, but this is a good starting point for updating the list, anyway. As a funny aside (which I mentioned years ago in this very post!), the addition of the skirmish camp at Harndirion really bloated the numbers of the Grey Company and made Tur Morva even worse than it was going to be. If it was up to me I wouldn't have made the guys at Harndirion Rangers, but once they were we had to account for them. :P

Lost in Tur Morva:
Amrúnir, Anglaer, Annúdhrod, Areneth, Badhordam, Balchelos, Banganir, Baradír, Braigiar, Cannuion, Celenath, Calatherdir, Demúr (the Ranger, not the Elf. Don't really know what the Elf's deal is), Dúnhammad, Duvengris, Fainneleg, Ferrif, Galasebdir, Gemniphred, Gernad, Handarod, Himeinior, Iorecthel, Legrindavor, Maedhrusc, Nidgyl, and Orchith

I'm not going to do the same thing for Pelennor casualties yet, because there's still drama to get from some of those in-game.

MoL

Thank you very much for this, MoL.

Its sad to see some important names on this list - Areneth, for instance, appeared to be quite the beast (it may just be that he's cunningly standing at the top of the slope up to Gath Forthnir, and as such looks taller!), and the names Balchelos, Cannuion, Calatherdir, Fainneleg, Ferrif, Galasebdir, Himeinior and Maedhrusc also stand out as Rangers that we interacted with before the Grey Company rode south.

After some serious colour coding on my end (and with help from one_ring's list above), I've got a list of those whose fates (post-Tur Morva) are unaccounted for. There are 11 of these:
- Amarion (still not going to accept he's dead until there's confirmation that Saruman or one of his servants captured him!)
- Brungos
- Culang (the riddle guy, woo!)
- Helchon
- Idhrenfair (originally Mirkwood, later sends you to meet the Hobbits of the Mournshaws)
- Idhrien
- Mincham (pursued by the dead!)
- Naeglanc (the mysterious leader of Echad Naeglanc!)
- Nestadron
- Nethraw (the seven swords!)
- Tugonn (Aragorn's old travelling companion, also found in Ost Dunhoth)

Total = 11

If we add these to those we met in Pelargir:
- Amlan
- Angwedh
- Calenglad
- Celairant
- Corunir
- Daervunn
- Dagoras (doesn't actually appear at Pelargir, but Lothrandir mentions him, so I assume he was still around at this point)
- Faeron
- Golodir
- Langlas
- Lothrandir
- Mandan
- Mithrendan
- Orthonn
- Prestadir
- Radanir
- Techeron

Total = 17 (if we include Halbarad and the sons of Elrond, that goes up to 20 - if we include Halros, that's 21).

Therefore, if we add those two lists up, and assuming that there are no unnamed characters in the Grey Company post-Pelargir, at most there are 32 rangers that meet Aragorn near the Fords of Isen.

If we discount Halros (because, as we know, his membership of the Grey Company is up to the player), then we're still left with 31 - and according to what I can find online (I've mislaid my novels!), that's the total number of the Grey Company when they meet Aragorn (including Halbarad and the sons of Elrond). I'm hoping this means that Amarion is safe up until this point, although if we take Halros into account, the poor ranger of Amon Raith may be a goner!