Quote Originally Posted by Hephburz-2 View Post
His argument still remains a valid one though, if these 3 lines also had the morale to match a YCaptain and if BChamp had adequate cooldowns, they could all easily rival a YCaptain on raw tanking ability alone (no, not in terms of support).
Well no, his argument essentially boils down to "Changing/Buffing BPE helps close the gap between Captains and the other tanks" when in reality a boost to the effectiveness of BPE benefits Captains almost as much as it benefits Guardians. BBeornings can stack morale almost as well as Captains on live, have a very strong defensive cooldown, and have notably better aggro management yet they still can't compete with YCaptain. YCaptain support is severely overtuned, the current bout of changes definitely knock YCaptains down to BGuard/BBeorning levels defensively but YCaptains can still perform as a support role whilst tanking and that is ridiculous.

YCaptain support still needs to be dialled back and the spec needs to have its aggro capabilities improved to the point where you can realistically generate at least some aggro outside of forced taunts.